Products that you might evaluate include films, books, albums, video games, tools, or other physical products.
Purpose and Audience: For this assignment, you are to provide an in-depth evaluation (not a summary) of how effective your selected product is at reaching a specific audience. You will need to base your evaluation on 3–4 specific criteria suited to the product you’re evaluating.
How to Achieve Your Purpose:
- Title: Include an interesting title that grabs readers’ attention and provides some information about your topic
- Introduction
- Grab the readers’ attention with a “hook.”
- Provide some background information about your topic and purpose.
- Identify the audience whose perspective you’ll consider in your evaluation.
- Include a direct evaluative thesis statement at the end of your first body paragraph that previews some of the pros/cons of your product and introduces the specific criteria upon which your product will be evaluated.
- Body Paragraphs
- Choose one of the following options for organizing your body paragraphs:
- Option 1: Each body paragraph discusses your product’s strengths and weaknesses in relation to each criterion. For example, if you evaluate a film based on plot, dialogue, acting, and visual effects, your paragraphs would be organized this way:
- Strengths and weaknesses of plot
- Strengths and weaknesses of dialogue
- Strengths and weaknesses of acting
- Strengths and weaknesses of visual effects
- Option 2: Two paragraphs discussing strengths and two paragraphs discussing weaknesses. For example,
- Strengths of plot, dialogue, acting, and/or visual effects
- Weaknesses of plot, dialogue, acting, and/or visual effects
- For each topic sentence, make an evaluative claim that the paragraph will support.
- Your supporting sentences should do the following:
- Make specific claims about the product’s strengths and weaknesses.
- Anticipate and respond to counter-arguments or other opinions.
- Refer to specific examples, quotes, and/or paraphrases about the product to support your claim.
- Explain why the examples, quotes, and/or paraphrases you refer to are effective or ineffective for the audience you’re considering.
- Quote and/or paraphrase at least THREE sources related to your product to support your argument. (For a film, book, or album, you must quote/and or paraphrase from the product itself.)
- Useful sources might include a credible source that evaluates the same product as yours or a similar product.
- Consider audience and rhetorical strategies—ethos, pathos, logos, and kairos.
- Wrap up each paragraph’s argument with a conclusion sentence.
- Option 1: Each body paragraph discusses your product’s strengths and weaknesses in relation to each criterion. For example, if you evaluate a film based on plot, dialogue, acting, and visual effects, your paragraphs would be organized this way:
- Conclusion
- Restate your main point with more emphasis.
- Look to the future by discussing possible future significance of the product.
*This essay will be graded according to rubric on the next page.